Conducted by Amphora Media in Malta and Prismag in Italy, the investigation examines different aspects of pre-trial detention and access to justice, drawing on official statistics, legal documents and interviews.
In Malta, Amphora Media examines prison population statistics, Forensic Unit data, access to legal aid and interpretation services, and the use of electronic tagging. The investigation draws on official documents, court and EU legal records, and interviews with NGOs, interpreters and a psychologist to explore the conditions and legal challenges affecting foreign nationals in the justice system.
In Italy, Prismag focuses on the situation of foreign nationals in detention, particularly their access to mental health services and alternatives to imprisonment. The investigation examines prison population statistics, suicide data and the availability of psychological and psychiatric support, highlighting imbalances in suicide events.
The Italian investigation also explores access to alternatives to detention for individuals without a registered residence, as well as the role of mediation and legal aid. Drawing on interviews with witnesses, lawyers, legal clinics, experts and the management of Rome's Regina Coeli prison, the reporting examines the legal and practical aspects of these issues.
Together, the investigations address pre-trial detention, mental health, legal assistance and alternatives to detention in Italy and Malta, with a particular focus on the potential systematic indirect discrimination faced by foreign nationals.
Methodology
The investigation combines freedom of information requests, analysis of official statistics and legal documents, and interviews conducted by Amphora Media in Malta and Prismag in Italy.
The research draws on prison population and suicide statistics, Forensic Unit data, mental health support, legal aid, interpretation, mediation, electronic tagging and alternatives to detention. Sources include national and EU legal documents, official reports, and interviews with witnesses, lawyers, NGOs, interpreters, mental health professionals, legal clinics, experts and prison authorities.
The project received expert support from Dr Francesca Vitarelli, PhD and research fellow in criminal law at the University of Milan. She provided expertise on human rights and migrants' access to justice, particularly in the context of EU law. Her contribution included consultancy on the analysis of data concerning migrants' detention and pre-trial conditions, as well as legal research on human rights violations. The team was also supported by project advisor Inga Springe.